How to Choose a Backend for Your First App: Firebase, Supabase or Custom
Does your app need a backend at all?
A backend is the part of an app that runs on a server rather than on the phone. You need one if users sign in, if data must be shared between people or devices, if the app sends push notifications, or if it takes payments. An app that keeps everything on one phone, such as a simple timer or calculator, may not need one.
If you do need one, there are three common starting points: Firebase, Supabase or a backend built for your app. Each is a reasonable choice in the right situation.
What is Firebase?
Firebase is Google's app development platform. Its main database, Cloud Firestore, is a cloud-hosted NoSQL database that stores data as documents grouped into collections. Google's Firestore documentation describes official SDKs for Android, Apple platforms and the web, real-time updates when data changes, and offline support, so the app can keep reading and writing data while the phone has no connection and sync it later. Firebase Authentication handles sign-in with email and password, phone numbers and providers such as Google.
Firebase suits apps where data is naturally shaped as separate records per user, and where offline use and live updates matter.
What is Supabase?
Supabase is a backend platform built around a relational database. Its database documentation states that every project gets a full Postgres database. Access from the app is controlled with Postgres Row Level Security, which sets rules for who can read or change each row. Supabase Auth handles sign-in and stores its data in the same Postgres database.
Supabase suits apps whose data has many relationships, such as orders, customers and products that refer to each other, and teams that want to query their data with standard SQL.
When does a custom backend make sense?
A custom backend is a server application written for your app. It takes longer to build, because sign-in, data access and hosting have to be set up rather than configured. It makes sense when:
- The business logic is complex and should not run on the phone, such as pricing rules or approval steps.
- You must connect to existing systems, such as a company ERP or a payment provider with specific requirements.
- Rules about data location or security require control over where and how data is stored.
- The data model has outgrown what a managed platform handles comfortably.
For a first release, many apps start on a managed platform and move parts to a custom service later, once real use shows where the limits are.
Which questions decide the choice?
| Question | Points towards |
|---|---|
| Is the data mostly separate records per user? | Firebase |
| Does the data have many relationships you need to query? | Supabase |
| Must the app work well offline? | Firebase, or careful design on either |
| Do you need to connect to existing company systems? | Custom, or a managed platform plus a small custom service |
| Do you want to avoid tying the app to one vendor? | Supabase or custom, because Postgres runs in many places |
There is no single right answer. The wrong answer is choosing before you know the shape of your data.
What about cost and lock-in?
Managed platforms remove setup work, but you pay for usage and you depend on the vendor's features and limits. Both publish their current plans on their pricing pages (Firebase pricing, Supabase pricing), and costs depend on how many people use the app and how often. Estimate your usage before you commit, and check how you would export your data if you ever needed to move. The main ThynkBlox blog compares the two database styles in more depth in PostgreSQL vs MongoDB for new products.
How does the backend affect testing and maintenance?
The backend is part of the app, so it needs the same care. Test what happens when a request fails or the network drops, as our guide on how to test an Android app before release explains. After launch, backend services and their SDKs change too. Our guide to what app maintenance involves after launch covers keeping them up to date.
Not sure which backend fits your app? Our backend and integrations work covers sign-in, data, payments and notifications as part of the build. Questions about code and account ownership are answered in our FAQ.